Level 3 · Mind-benders · 13 min
The Ship of Theseus: Who Are You?
An ancient puzzle about planks becomes a modern question about memory, bodies and the self.
Before we begin — what would you do?
Every plank of a ship is replaced, one by one. Is it the same ship?
Part 1
The puzzle
Plutarch told of Theseus' ship, its rotting planks replaced until none were original. Now gather the old planks and rebuild them. Which ship is Theseus'?
Part 2
Locke: memory makes the person
Locke argued that personal identity lies in consciousness — the chain of memory linking you now to you then. A prince's mind in a cobbler's body would be the prince.
Part 3
Parfit: identity is not what matters
Imagine a teleporter that destroys you and builds an exact copy on Mars. Parfit concluded what matters is psychological continuity, not a hidden 'self' — a thought he found liberating.
Part 4
Today
Uploading minds, deep fakes, dementia care: the ship sails into our century. Who we are is a practical question now.
Still wondering? Ask them yourself.
Test your understanding
1. Locke located personal identity in…
2. Parfit's teleporter case suggests…
3. The Ship of Theseus originally comes from…