Agora.
← Lessons

Level 3 · Mind-benders · 13 min

The Ship of Theseus: Who Are You?

An ancient puzzle about planks becomes a modern question about memory, bodies and the self.

Before we begin — what would you do?

Every plank of a ship is replaced, one by one. Is it the same ship?

Part 1

The puzzle

Plutarch told of Theseus' ship, its rotting planks replaced until none were original. Now gather the old planks and rebuild them. Which ship is Theseus'?

Part 2

Locke: memory makes the person

Locke argued that personal identity lies in consciousness — the chain of memory linking you now to you then. A prince's mind in a cobbler's body would be the prince.

Part 3

Parfit: identity is not what matters

Imagine a teleporter that destroys you and builds an exact copy on Mars. Parfit concluded what matters is psychological continuity, not a hidden 'self' — a thought he found liberating.

Part 4

Today

Uploading minds, deep fakes, dementia care: the ship sails into our century. Who we are is a practical question now.

Still wondering? Ask them yourself.

Test your understanding

  1. 1. Locke located personal identity in…

  2. 2. Parfit's teleporter case suggests…

  3. 3. The Ship of Theseus originally comes from…